PIAA tightens competitive balance formula for football, basketball transfers
By:
Friday, October 4, 2019 | 2:03 PM
Lincoln Park’s Keeno Holmes and Johnnie Bryant celebrate with the championship trophy after defeating Trinity, 73-72, to win the PIAA Class 3A boys state final Saturday, Mar. 23, 2019, at Giant Center in Hershey.
Vincentian senior Drew McBrier holds the PIAA Class A runner-up trophy with teammates after the Royals’ 83-61 loss to Sankofa Freedom Academy in the state final Thursday, Mar. 21, 2019, at Giant Center in Hershey.
Chartiers Valley’s Mackenzie Wagner kisses the championship trophy with teammates after defeating Bishop Carroll in the PIAA Class 5A girls state championship game Saturday, Mar. 23, 2019, at Giant Center in Hershey.
Penn Hills’ Daequan Hardy accepts the state championship trophy after the Indians defeated Manheim Central in the PIAA Class 5A final Friday, Dec. 7, 2018, at Hersheypark Stadium.
Adding one transfer could force a basketball team into a higher PIAA classification.
The PIAA board this week voted to tighten its competitive balance formula by reducing the number of transfers required to trigger an increase in classification. The threshold in football was reduced from five transfers to three, and basketball was reduced from two transfers to one.
“It’s a big move,” PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi said.
The tighter restrictions are intended to better regulate small-school teams.
“A smaller number really can have an impact there,” Lombardi said. “Three football players or one good basketball player moving to the smaller classifications of schools — A, 2A or 3A — has a much bigger impact than those numbers for the larger schools.
“To be consistent across the classifications, the board felt that those lower numbers more fully addressed competitive balance.”
However, before being forced to move up, a team also must accumulate six “success points” during a two-year PIAA cycle.
Teams can earn between one and four points each postseason based on how far they advance in the PIAA playoffs. For example, a state finalist receives four points.
The competitive balance formula affects only football and basketball.
The PIAA began tabulating success points during the 2018-19 school year. The data collected will be used for the 2020-21 and 2021-22 realignment, Lombardi said.
Eight WPIAL teams already have accumulated four success points:
Football: Aliquippa, Penn Hills
Boys basketball: Lincoln Park, Moon, Vincentian Academy
Girls basketball: Chartiers Valley, North Catholic, Peters Township
Chris Harlan is a TribLive reporter covering sports. He joined the Trib in 2009 after seven years as a reporter at the Beaver County Times. He can be reached at charlan@triblive.com.
Tags: Aliquippa, Chartiers Valley, Lincoln Park, Moon, North Catholic, Penn Hills, Peters Township, Vincentian Academy
More High School Basketball
• With young lineup, Freeport girls look to keep things simple• With revamped roster, Freeport boys looking to develop identity
• Hempfield boys plan to pick up pace, close out more wins
• With plenty of size in starting lineup, Shady Side Academy boys embrace modern game
• With new mix of players, Hempfield girls up for challenge in tough 6A section
